During the January 2013 haze episode over central and eastern China, sulfate concentrations grew far faster than gas-phase chemistry could explain, and chemical transport models systematically underpredicted sulfate unless empirical heterogeneous uptake was added. The source study (Wang et al., 2014) attributed the episode's explosive PM2.5 growth to fast secondary transformation of SO2 catalyzed indirectly by the abnormally high NOx, proceeding via heterogeneous reactions on particle surfaces. The responsible surface/aqueous reaction mechanisms, oxidants, and regime thresholds were then unquantified, and key radical and oxidant species were unmeasured. A decade of laboratory, field, and modeling studies has produced at least ten competing mechanistic proposals (NO2 and HONO oxidation in aerosol water, hydrogen peroxide in deliquesced particles, transition-metal-ion and manganese surface catalysis, nitrate photolysis, mineral-dust-catalyzed routes, and hydroxymethanesulfonate as a sulfur reservoir), whose attributions remain inconsistent and even contradictory. The open core is a validated, community-accepted quantitative apportionment of rapid wintertime sulfate production among these multiphase pathways, with their chemical-regime dependence (aerosol pH, liquid water content, relative humidity, metal loading, oxidant supply), sufficient for models to reproduce observed sulfate formation rates without empirically tuned parameters.

Background

PM2.5 (particulate matter with aerodynamic diameter below 2.5 micrometers) is the dominant pollutant in severe winter haze over the North China Plain. Its secondary inorganic fraction — sulfate, nitrate, and ammonium — is produced in the atmosphere from gaseous precursors, chiefly sulfur dioxide (SO2SO_2) from coal combustion. Converting SO2SO_2 to sulfate (SO42−SO_4^{2-}) requires oxidation: in the gas phase the main oxidant is the hydroxyl radical (OH), while in cloud droplets the dissolved S(IV) species (sulfite and bisulfite) are oxidized by hydrogen peroxide (H2O2H_2O_2) or ozone (O3O_3). 'Heterogeneous' chemistry denotes reactions on or inside aerosol particles rather than in the gas phase or cloud water; 'aqueous-phase' or multiphase aerosol chemistry occurs in the liquid water that hygroscopic particles absorb at high relative humidity (RH), quantified as aerosol liquid water content. Because S(IV) speciation and the rates of most oxidants depend strongly on acidity, the aerosol pH (a thermodynamic quantity usually inferred from measured ion compositions via equilibrium models such as ISORROPIA-II, not measured directly) controls which pathway is active. Transition-metal ions (TMIs, mainly Fe and Mn, supplied largely by mineral dust and fly ash) catalyze S(IV) oxidation by oxygen, both in bulk solution and on particle surfaces. Nitrogen dioxide (NO2NO_2), abundant in urban winter air, oxidizes S(IV) appreciably only when the solution is not acidic; nitrous acid (HONO) and particulate nitrate photolysis have been proposed as additional oxidant sources. Hydroxymethanesulfonate (HMS), the adduct of hydrated formaldehyde and bisulfite, can be misidentified as sulfate in standard ion-chromatography measurements, inflating apparent sulfate.

The quantitative puzzle was established for the January 2013 episode itself: observations showed PM2.5 exceeding 500-680 μg m−3\mu g\,m^{-3} in Beijing with sulfate the fastest-growing component, while models capturing SO2SO_2 and meteorology underpredicted sulfate growth; reproducing observations required empirically enhanced heterogeneous uptake coefficients (Wang Y. et al. 2014; Zheng B. et al. 2015). The source study (Wang Y. S. et al. 2014) documented the episode across 11 ground sites and identified fast secondary transformation of primary gases — with high NOx playing a direct or indirect role in rapid SO2SO_2-to-sulfate conversion via heterogeneous surface reactions — as the internal cause. The responsible surface reaction mechanisms were unidentified, key oxidants and radicals (OH, HO2HO_2, H2O2H_2O_2, peroxynitric acid) were not measured, the partitioning between low-RH surface reactions and high-RH aqueous oxidation (regime transition near RH of roughly 50%, where particle liquid water becomes abundant) was unquantified, and the role of superposed long-range dust in modulating particle catalytic capacity was unresolved. Since then, field campaigns have measured winter OH and ROxRO_x (the sum of OH, HO2HO_2, and organic peroxy radicals) and H2O2H_2O_2 in Beijing, laboratory work has measured kinetics on deliquesced particles, dust, and under nitrate photolysis, and observation-constrained box and 3-D models have produced apportionments — but these apportionments disagree: NO2-in-aerosol-water chemistry (Cheng et al. 2016; Wang G. et al. 2016) was challenged by pH estimates near 4.2-5 showing the route to be negligible (Liu M. et al. 2017; Tao et al. 2020); manganese-catalyzed surface oxidation was found dominant in some apportionments (Wang W. et al. 2021; Wang T. et al. 2022; Liu M. et al. 2024) while H2O2H_2O_2 aqueous oxidation was found dominant in another (Gao et al. 2022); and new surface-catalyzed NO2 routes were still being proposed in 2025 (Liu P. et al. 2025).

Problem Statement

Identify and quantitatively attribute the mechanism or combination of multiphase mechanisms responsible for the rapid SO2SO_2-to-sulfate conversion observed during severe winter haze episodes in northern China, such as those of January 2013, and validate this attribution against concurrent ambient observations. The four completion components below operationalize this open core as documented in the cited debate literature. A complete answer must (1) tabulate the reaction-level rate constants or uptake parameters reported in the literature and measured under atmospherically relevant conditions, for each of the following candidate pathways, which together define the required pathway coverage — gas-phase OH oxidation; aqueous-phase oxidation by H2O2H_2O_2, O3O_3, NO2NO_2/HONO, and TMI-catalyzed O2O_2 oxidation in aerosol water; surface reactions on mineral-dust and carbonaceous particles, including Mn- or Cu-catalyzed surface routes and nitrate-photolysis-driven oxidation; and formation of HMS where it masquerades as sulfate in measurements; (2) delineate the chemical regimes — aerosol pH, relative humidity/aerosol liquid water content, TMI loading, oxidant supply, temperature — within which each pathway dominates, giving the numeric value of each regime boundary, including the threshold conditions for the transition from surface-dominated to aqueous-dominated production; (3) apportion the observed sulfate formation rate among these pathways during actual haze episodes, with uncertainties, using simultaneously measured precursor, oxidant/radical, aerosol-composition, and meteorological data rather than empirically tuned uptake coefficients; and (4) demonstrate closure by running or reproducing a chemical transport model or observation-constrained box model that incorporates this attribution and reproduces the observed episode-scale sulfate production rates — the observation-constrained characteristic sulfate formation rates being a median of about 70 μg m−3 day−170\,\mu g\,m^{-3}\,day^{-1} with a 90% interval of 2525-165 μg m−3 day−1165\,\mu g\,m^{-3}\,day^{-1} across recent northern-China winter haze episodes, and a peak-based estimate of about 12 μg m−3 h−112\,\mu g\,m^{-3}\,h^{-1} for the severe January 2013 episode (Liu M. et al. 2024) — together with their RH/pH regime dependence, without ad hoc enhancement factors or empirically tuned uptake coefficients. The four components are jointly required and complementary rather than alternative: component (3) is the observation-based apportionment of the observed sulfate formation rate, whereas component (4) is an independent forward-model closure test that reproduces the observed episode-scale rates, so completing (3) does not by itself satisfy (4).

References

  1. Wang YueSi, Yao Li, Wang LiLi, Liu ZiRui, Ji DongSheng, Tang GuiQian, Zhang JunKe, Sun Yang, Hu Bo, Xin JinYuan (2014). Mechanism for the formation of the January 2013 heavy haze pollution episode over central and eastern China. Science China Earth Sciences 57:14-25. doi:10.1007/s11430-013-4773-4 | https://doi.org/10.1007/s11430-013-4773-4
  2. Wang Yuxuan, Zhang Qianqian, Jiang Jingkun, Zhou Wei, Wang Buying, He Kebin, Duan Fengkui, Zhang Qian, Philip Sajeev, Xie Yuanyu (2014). Enhanced sulfate formation during China's severe winter haze episode in January 2013 missing from current models. Journal of Geophysical Research: Atmospheres 119(17). doi:10.1002/2013jd021426 | https://doi.org/10.1002/2013jd021426
  3. Huang Ru-Jin, Zhang Yanlin, Bozzetti Carlo, Ho Kin-Fai, Cao Jun-Ji, Han Yongming, Daellenbach Kaspar R., Slowik Jay G., Platt Stephen M., Canonaco Francesco, Zotter Peter, Wolf Robert, Pieber Simone M., Bruns Emily A., Crippa Monica, Ciarelli Giancarlo, Piazzalunga Andrea, Schwikowski Margit, Abbaszade Gulcin, Schnelle-Kreis Jurgen, Zimmermann Ralf, An Zhisheng, Szidat Sonke, Baltensperger Urs, Haddad Imad El, Prevot Andre S. H. (2014). High secondary aerosol contribution to particulate pollution during haze events in China. Nature 514:218-222. doi:10.1038/nature13774 | https://doi.org/10.1038/nature13774
  4. Huang Xin, Song Yu, Zhao Chun, Li Mengmeng, Zhu Tong, Zhang Qiang, Zhang Xiaoye (2014). Pathways of sulfate enhancement by natural and anthropogenic mineral aerosols in China. Journal of Geophysical Research: Atmospheres 119(24). doi:10.1002/2014jd022301 | https://doi.org/10.1002/2014jd022301
  5. Zheng Bo, Zhang Qiang, Zhang Yixuan, He Kebin, Wang Kan, Zheng Guojie, Duan Fengkui, Ma Yongliang, Kimoto Toshimasa (2015). Heterogeneous chemistry: a mechanism missing in current models to explain secondary inorganic aerosol formation during the January 2013 haze episode in North China. Atmospheric Chemistry and Physics 15:2031-2049. doi:10.5194/acp-15-2031-2015 | https://doi.org/10.5194/acp-15-2031-2015
  6. Cheng Yafang, Zheng Guangjie, Wei Chao, Mu Qing, Zheng Bo, Wang Zhibin, Gao Meng, Zhang Qiang, He Kebin, Carmichael Gregory, Poschl Ulrich, Su Hang (2016). Reactive nitrogen chemistry in aerosol water as a source of sulfate during haze events in China. Science Advances 2:e1601530. doi:10.1126/sciadv.1601530 | https://doi.org/10.1126/sciadv.1601530
  7. Wang Gehui, Zhang Renyi, Gomez Mario E., Yang Lingxiao, Levy Zamora Misti, Hu Min, Lin Yun, Peng Jianfei, Guo Song, Meng Jingjing, Li Jianjun, Cheng Chunlei, Hu Tafeng, Ren Yanqin, Wang Yuesi, Gao Jian, Cao Junji, An Zhisheng, Zhou Weijian, Li Guohui, Wang Jiayuan, Tian Pengfei, Marrero-Ortiz Wilmarie, Secrest Jeremiah, Du Zhuofei, Zheng Jing, Shang Dongjie, Zeng Limin, Shao Min, Wang Weigang, Huang Yao, Wang Yuan, Zhu Yujiao, Li Yixin, Hu Jiaxi, Pan Bowen, Cai Li, Cheng Yuting, Ji Yuemeng, Zhang Fang, Rosenfeld Daniel, Liss Peter S., Duce Robert A., Kolb Charles E., Molina Mario J. (2016). Persistent sulfate formation from London Fog to Chinese haze. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 113:13630-13635. doi:10.1073/pnas.1616540113 | https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.1616540113
  8. Liu Mingxu, Song Yu, Zhou Tian, Xu Zhenying, Yan Caiqing, Zheng Mei, Wu Zhijun, Hu Min, Wu Yusheng, Zhu Tong (2017). Fine particle pH during severe haze episodes in northern China. Geophysical Research Letters 44:5213-5221. doi:10.1002/2017GL073210 | https://doi.org/10.1002/2017GL073210
  9. Moch Jonathan M., Dovrou Eleni, Mickley Loretta J., Keutsch Frank N., Cheng Yuan, Jacob Daniel J., Jiang Jingkun, Li Meng, Munger J. William, Qiao Xiaohui, Zhang Qiang (2018). Contribution of Hydroxymethane Sulfonate to Ambient Particulate Matter: A Potential Explanation for High Particulate Sulfur During Severe Winter Haze in Beijing. Geophysical Research Letters 45(21). doi:10.1029/2018GL079309 | https://doi.org/10.1029/2018GL079309
  10. Tan Zhaofeng, Rohrer Franz, Lu Keding, Ma Xuefei, Bohn Birger, Broch Sebastian, Dong Huabin, Fuchs Hendrik, Gkatzelis Georgios I., Hofzumahaus Andreas, Holland Frank, Li Xin, Liu Ying, Liu Yuhan, Novelli Anna, Shao Min, Wang Haichao, Wu Yusheng, Zeng Limin, Hu Min, Kiendler-Scharr Astrid, Wahner Andreas, Zhang Yuanhang (2018). Wintertime photochemistry in Beijing: observations of ROx radical concentrations in the North China Plain during the BEST-ONE campaign. Atmospheric Chemistry and Physics 18:12391-12411. doi:10.5194/acp-18-12391-2018 | https://doi.org/10.5194/acp-18-12391-2018
  11. Ye Can, Liu Pengfei, Ma Zhuobiao, Xue Chaoyang, Zhang Chenglong, Zhang Yuanyuan, Liu Junfeng, Liu Chengtang, Sun Xu, Mu Yujing (2018). High H2O2 Concentrations Observed during Haze Periods during the Winter in Beijing: Importance of H2O2 Oxidation in Sulfate Formation. Environmental Science & Technology Letters 5:757-763. doi:10.1021/acs.estlett.8b00579 | https://doi.org/10.1021/acs.estlett.8b00579
  12. Xue Jian, Yu Xin, Yuan Zibing, Griffith Stephen M., Lau Alexis K. H., Seinfeld John H., Yu Jian Zhen (2019). Efficient control of atmospheric sulfate production based on three formation regimes. Nature Geoscience 12:977-982. doi:10.1038/s41561-019-0485-5 | https://doi.org/10.1038/s41561-019-0485-5
  13. Zhang Yue, Bao Fengxia, Li Meng, Chen Chuncheng, Zhao Jincai (2019). Nitrate-Enhanced Oxidation of SO2 on Mineral Dust: A Vital Role of a Proton. Environmental Science & Technology 53:10139-10145. doi:10.1021/acs.est.9b01921 | https://doi.org/10.1021/acs.est.9b01921
  14. Gen Masao, Zhang Ruifeng, Huang Dan Dan, Li Yongjie, Chan Chak K. (2019). Heterogeneous Oxidation of SO2 in Sulfate Production during Nitrate Photolysis at 300 nm: Effect of pH, Relative Humidity, Irradiation Intensity, and the Presence of Organic Compounds. Environmental Science & Technology 53:8757-8766. doi:10.1021/acs.est.9b01623 | https://doi.org/10.1021/acs.est.9b01623
  15. Fang Yanhua, Ye Chunxiang, Wang Junxia, Wu Yusheng, Hu Min, Lin Weili, Xu Fanfan, Zhu Tong (2019). Relative humidity and O3 concentration as two prerequisites for sulfate formation. Atmospheric Chemistry and Physics 19:12295-12307. doi:10.5194/acp-19-12295-2019 | https://doi.org/10.5194/acp-19-12295-2019
  16. Tao Wei, Su Hang, Zheng Guangjie, Wang Jiandong, Wei Chao, Liu Lixia, Ma Nan, Li Meng, Zhang Qiang, Poschl Ulrich, Cheng Yafang (2020). Aerosol pH and chemical regimes of sulfate formation in aerosol water during winter haze in the North China Plain. Atmospheric Chemistry and Physics 20:11729-11746. doi:10.5194/acp-20-11729-2020 | https://doi.org/10.5194/acp-20-11729-2020
  17. Liu Tengyu, Clegg Simon L., Abbatt Jonathan P. D. (2020). Fast oxidation of sulfur dioxide by hydrogen peroxide in deliquesced aerosol particles. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 117:1354-1359. doi:10.1073/pnas.1916401117 | https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.1916401117
  18. Wang Junfeng, Li Jingyi, Ye Jianhuai, Zhao Jian, Wu Yangzhou, Hu Jianlin, Liu Dantong, Nie Dongyang, Shen Fuzhen, Huang Xiangpeng, Huang Dan Dan, Ji Dongsheng, Sun Xu, Xu Weiqi, Guo Jianping, Song Shaojie, Qin Yiming, Liu Pengfei, Turner Jay R., Lee Hyun Chul, Hwang Sungwoo, Liao Hong, Martin Scot T., Zhang Qi, Chen Mindong, Sun Yele, Ge Xinlei, Jacob Daniel J. (2020). Fast sulfate formation from oxidation of SO2 by NO2 and HONO observed in Beijing haze. Nature Communications 11:2844. doi:10.1038/s41467-020-16683-x | https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-020-16683-x
  19. Zheng Haotian, Song Shaojie, Sarwar Golam, Gen Masao, Wang Shuxiao, Ding Dian, Chang Xing, Zhang Shuping, Xing Jia, Sun Yele, Ji Dongsheng, Chan Chak K., Gao Jian, McElroy Michael B. (2020). Contribution of Particulate Nitrate Photolysis to Heterogeneous Sulfate Formation for Winter Haze in China. Environmental Science & Technology Letters 7:632-638. doi:10.1021/acs.estlett.0c00368 | https://doi.org/10.1021/acs.estlett.0c00368
  20. Slater Eloise J., Whalley Lisa K., Woodward-Massey Robert, Ye Chunxiang, Lee James D., Squires Freya, Hopkins James R., Dunmore Rachel E., Shaw Marvin, Hamilton Jacqueline F., Lewis Alastair C., Crilley Leigh R., Kramer Louisa, Bloss William, Vu Tuan, Sun Yele, Xu Weiqi, Yue Siyao, Ren Lujie, Acton W. Joe F., Hewitt C. Nicholas, Wang Xinming, Fu Pingqing, Heard Dwayne E. (2020). Elevated levels of OH observed in haze events during wintertime in central Beijing. Atmospheric Chemistry and Physics 20:14847-14871. doi:10.5194/acp-20-14847-2020 | https://doi.org/10.5194/acp-20-14847-2020
  21. Angle Kyle J., Neal Erin E., Grassian Vicki H. (2021). Enhanced Rates of Transition-Metal-Ion-Catalyzed Oxidation of S(IV) in Aqueous Aerosols: Insights into Sulfate Aerosol Formation in the Atmosphere. Environmental Science & Technology 55:10291-10299. doi:10.1021/acs.est.1c01932 | https://doi.org/10.1021/acs.est.1c01932
  22. Liu Tengyu, Abbatt Jonathan P. D. (2021). Oxidation of sulfur dioxide by nitrogen dioxide accelerated at the interface of deliquesced aerosol particles. Nature Chemistry 13:1173-1177. doi:10.1038/s41557-021-00777-0 | https://doi.org/10.1038/s41557-021-00777-0
  23. Ye Can, Chen Hui, Hoffmann Erik H., Mettke Peter, Tilgner Andreas, He Lin, Mutzel Anke, Bruggemann Martin, Poulain Laurent, Schaefer Thomas, Heinold Bernd, Ma Zhuobiao, Liu Pengfei, Xue Chaoyang, Zhao Xiaoxi, Zhang Chenglong, Zhang Fei, Sun Hao, Li Qing, Wang Lin, Yang Xin, Wang Jinhe, Liu Cheng, Xing Chengzhi, Mu Yujing, Chen Jianmin, Herrmann Hartmut (2021). Particle-Phase Photoreactions of HULIS and TMIs Establish a Strong Source of H2O2 and Particulate Sulfate in the Winter North China Plain. Environmental Science & Technology 55:7818-7830. doi:10.1021/acs.est.1c00561 | https://doi.org/10.1021/acs.est.1c00561
  24. Wang Weigang, Liu Mingyuan, Wang Tiantian, Song Yu, Zhou Li, Cao Junji, Hu Jingnan, Tang Guigang, Chen Zhe, Li Zhijie, Xu Zhenying, Peng Chao, Lian Chaofan, Chen Yan, Pan Yuepeng, Zhang Yunhong, Sun Yele, Li Weijun, Zhu Tong, Tian Hezhong, Ge Maofa (2021). Sulfate formation is dominated by manganese-catalyzed oxidation of SO2 on aerosol surfaces during haze events. Nature Communications 12:1993. doi:10.1038/s41467-021-22091-6 | https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-021-22091-6
  25. Gao Jie, Shi Guoliang, Zhang Zhongcheng, Wei Yuting, Tian Xiao, Feng Yinchang, Russell Armistead G., Nenes Athanasios (2022). Targeting Atmospheric Oxidants Can Better Reduce Sulfate Aerosol in China: H2O2 Aqueous Oxidation Pathway Dominates Sulfate Formation in Haze. Environmental Science & Technology 56:10608-10618. doi:10.1021/acs.est.2c01739 | https://doi.org/10.1021/acs.est.2c01739
  26. Wang Tiantian, Liu Mingxu, Liu Mingyuan, Song Yu, Xu Zhenying, Shang Fang, Huang Xin, Liao Wenling, Wang Weigang, Ge Maofa, Cao Junji, Hu Jingnan, Tang Guigang, Pan Yuepeng, Hu Min, Zhu Tong (2022). Sulfate Formation Apportionment during Winter Haze Events in North China. Environmental Science & Technology 56:7771-7778. doi:10.1021/acs.est.2c02533 | https://doi.org/10.1021/acs.est.2c02533
  27. Liu Mingxu, Song Yu, Wang Tiantian, Dang Xinyi, Shang Fang, Jin Xipeng, Du Mile, Wang Weigang, Sun Yele, Zhang Qiang, Kang Ling, Cai Xuhui, Zhang Hongsheng, Zhu Tong (2024). Can we reach consensus on the dominant sulfate formation pathway in China's haze?. PNAS Nexus 3:pgae291. doi:10.1093/pnasnexus/pgae291 | https://doi.org/10.1093/pnasnexus/pgae291
  28. Liu Pai, Liu Yu-Xin, Huang Qishen, Chao Xinyue, Zhong Mingrui, Yin Jiayi, Zhang Xiaowu, Li Lin-Fang, Kang Xi-Yuan, Chen Zhe, Pang Shufeng, Wang Weigang, Zhang Yun-Hong, Ge Maofa (2025). Sulfate formation through copper-catalyzed SO2 oxidation by NO2 at aerosol surfaces. npj Climate and Atmospheric Science 8:57. doi:10.1038/s41612-025-00934-z | https://doi.org/10.1038/s41612-025-00934-z