In 2016, Conde and co-workers reported that Fe(II) and Mn(II) complexes of the tetradentate pytacn ligand, made dicationic by anion abstraction and combined with ethyl diazoacetate, functionalize non-activated arene C(sp²)–H bonds with complete chemoselectivity — neither Buchner ring expansion nor benzylic C(sp³)–H insertion competes — and posed a bundle of open questions: experimental characterization of the proposed dicationic active species and metallocarbene, theoretical validation of the proposed outer-sphere electrophilic-aromatic-substitution pathway, the origins of ortho/meta/para regioselectivity and of the failure of electron-poor arenes, and the generality of the strategy. For iron, the mechanistic strand has been substantially resolved: Postils and co-workers' 2018 combined density-functional-theory (DFT) and experimental study established a stepwise electrophilic pathway whose key step is formation of an enol-like precursor of the insertion product. The remaining core is open: the dicationic species and the metallocarbene have never been structurally or spectroscopically characterized for either metal; no validated quantitative account exists of the regioisomer distributions in substituted arenes or of the deactivation of electron-poor arenes; the manganese analogue lacks its own mechanistic study; and the strategy has not been extended to other diazo reagents, functionalized or heteroaromatic substrates, or enantioselective variants, even though alternative platforms (gold, copper, scandium, photoredox, engineered enzymes) have advanced parts of the broader goal in parallel.

Background

Carbene insertion is a C–H functionalization manifold in which a diazo compound (here ethyl diazoacetate, EDA, N₂CHCO₂Et) loses N₂ at a transition-metal center to form a metallocarbene — a complex bearing a divalent, electrophilic carbon bound to the metal — that can insert into a C–H bond to forge a new C–C bond. Applying this manifold intermolecularly to arenes is notoriously difficult. Electrophilic metal carbenes react with benzene derivatives through several competing channels: the desired C(sp²)–H insertion; insertion into benzylic or other C(sp³)–H bonds when present; and the Buchner reaction, in which the carbene adds to the arene ring and the resulting norcaradiene rearranges to a cycloheptatriene. Classical rhodium, copper, and gold carbene systems typically need a large excess of arene (often as solvent), directing groups, or activated substrates, and frequently lose chemoselectivity; earlier iron-porphyrin systems showed only moderate selectivity between aromatic and benzylic insertion.

The breakthrough of Conde, Sabenya, Rodríguez, Postils, Luis, Díaz-Requejo, Costas, and Pérez (Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. 2016, 55, 6530–6534) was the first example of completely chemoselective direct functionalization of non-activated aryl C(sp²)–H bonds with EDA. The catalysts are Fe(II) or Mn(II) complexes of pytacn (1-(2-pyridylmethyl)-4,7-dimethyl-1,4,7-triazacyclononane), a tetradentate nitrogen-donor ligand from bioinspired non-heme oxidation chemistry; with anion abstraction (sodium tetrakis[3,5-bis(trifluoromethyl)phenyl]borate) a dicationic species is generated. Benzene and alkylbenzenes give ethyl arylacetates exclusively through C(sp²)–H insertion, leaving benzylic C(sp³)–H bonds untouched and forming only traces of Buchner products. Monosubstituted arenes react in moderate-to-good yields but as mixtures of ortho/meta/para regioisomers, and electron-poor arenes (for example chloro- and trifluoromethylbenzene) give low conversion. The authors proposed an outer-sphere mechanism: the dicationic species binds EDA, extrudes N₂ to give a metal carbene, the arene attacks the electrophilic carbene carbon in an electrophilic-aromatic-substitution step to form a Wheland-type σ-complex (an arenium cation), and a 1,2-hydrogen shift releases the product and regenerates the catalyst. They left open the structural characterization of the dicationic species and the metallocarbene, detailed theoretical validation of the pathway, the origin of the regioselectivity and of the electron-poor-arene deactivation, and the extension of the strategy to other diazo reagents, functionalized or heteroaromatic substrates, and enantioselective variants.

The mechanistic strand was subsequently addressed by the same teams. Postils, Rodríguez, Sabenya, Conde, Díaz-Requejo, Pérez, Costas, Solà, and Luis (ACS Catal. 2018, 8, 4313–4322) published the announced density-functional-theory (DFT) study together with substrate-probe and isotopic-labeling experiments for the iron system, computing the pathway for benzene and alkylbenzenes; the key finding is that a stepwise electrophilic pathway operates in which the crucial intermediate is an enol-like substrate that is the precursor of the final insertion product, which explains the exceptional chemoselectivity. Related work on cationic coinage-metal (Cu/Ag/Au) N-heterocyclic carbene complexes by Fructos, Besora, Braga, Díaz-Requejo, Maseras, and Pérez (Organometallics 2017, 36, 172–179) confirmed by experiment and DFT that arene C–H functionalization with EDA in these electrophilic-carbene systems proceeds stepwise, with metal-dependent competition from the Buchner reaction. Later computational work by Jindal and co-workers established metal-associated enol intermediates as a recurring motif across carbene-insertion chemistry and stressed that the structure of the catalytically active species remains unsettled even in mature systems; and in 2026, Díaz-Jiménez and co-workers achieved the first characterization of a silver vinylcarbene undergoing C(sp²)–H insertion, showing that such transient electrophilic carbenes can be intercepted experimentally and that the insertion mechanism can switch from the usual Wheland-type stepwise route to a concerted one depending on substitution.

Meanwhile, the broader goal of general arene C(sp²)–H alkylation with diazo compounds has advanced on other platforms: gold-catalyzed para-selective alkylation of benzene derivatives with α-aryl-α-diazoesters (Ma et al., 2017), iron-porphyrin-catalyzed ortho-selective functionalization of phenols and naphthols (Yu et al., 2021), scandium-catalyzed site-selective functionalization of unactivated and even mildly deactivated arenes with propargyl α-aryl-α-diazoacetates supported by DFT (Navale et al., 2022), metal-free photoredox arene C–H alkylation with diazoesters through arene radical cations (Holmberg-Douglas, Onuska, and Nicewicz, 2020), and engineered P450 (cytochrome-P450-enzyme) carbene transferases performing chemodivergent C(sp³)–H versus ortho-arene C(sp²)–H cyanomethylation (Zhang, Maggiolo, Alfonzo, Mao, Porter, Abney, and Arnold, Nat. Catal. 2023). None of these, however, characterizes the pytacn iron/manganese species or extends that system's own scope. Reviews of iron carbene chemistry and of transition-metal-catalyzed C–H carbene insertion (Batista et al. 2020; He et al. 2022; Balhara, Chatterjee, and Jindal 2024) uniformly treat the 2016 report and the 2018 mechanistic study as the reference case for base-metal arene C(sp²)–H carbene insertion, with no characterization of the pytacn intermediates and no scope extension reported.

Problem Statement

For the Fe(II)/Mn(II)-pytacn-catalyzed intermolecular functionalization of arene C(sp²)–H bonds by carbene insertion from ethyl diazoacetate (the catalytically active species being generated by anion abstraction from the metal triflate precursors), determine what remains undetermined since the 2016 report, in three jointly linked facets that together convert the empirical discovery into a mechanistically grounded and generally useful base-metal catalytic platform:

(1) Active-species and intermediate characterization. Establish experimentally the identity, oxidation state, spin state, and coordination geometry of the dicationic active species and of the metallocarbene intermediate, for both iron and manganese, together with a demonstration that any species so characterized is catalytically competent (stoichiometric transfer of the CHCO₂Et unit to an arene with the observed chemoselectivity). This facet is resolved by a determination — positive or negative — of the nature of the active species: either the experimental characterization specified above, or a demonstration that no discrete dicationic species or metallocarbene forms under catalytic conditions (for example, a concerted, carbene-free pathway); either outcome resolves the facet. To date these species are inferred only from kinetics, probe experiments, and computation.

(2) Origins of selectivity. Provide a validated quantitative account of the regioselectivity in substituted arenes — the observed ortho/meta/para product ratios — and of the sharply reduced reactivity of electron-poor arenes such as chlorobenzene and trifluoromethylbenzene, identifying the physical factors (electrophilicity of the metal carbene, relative barriers for formation and breakdown of Wheland-type intermediates versus competing channels) that govern them. Both phenomena are independently required — an account of the ortho/meta/para ratios does not discharge the electron-poor-arene deactivation, or vice versa — and the account is validated only when it is a falsifiable model whose computed barriers reproduce, or explicitly reconcile, the reported ratios and reactivities. The 2018 computational study covered benzene and alkylbenzenes and the chemoselectivity question; the substituted-arene regioselectivity and electron-poor-arene deactivation are unexplained, and the manganese system has had no dedicated mechanistic study of its own.

(3) Generality of the strategy. Determine whether the activation/selection strategy extends beyond ethyl diazoacetate and simple (alkyl)benzenes while preserving its defining complete C(sp²)–H selectivity over Buchner cycloheptatriene formation and benzylic C(sp³)–H insertion: to other diazo reagents (for example donor–acceptor α-aryl diazoesters or diazoketones), to functionalized and heteroaromatic substrates, and to enantioselective variants based on chiral pytacn-type ligand environments. The named reagents and substrates are illustrative of their classes, not an exhaustive list: these three extension classes are independent sub-questions, each resolved by a determination — positive or negative — at the level of the class of whether the strategy extends there with the defining selectivity retained or demonstrably lost.

The mechanistic understanding (facets 1 and 2) and the scope determination (facet 3) are posed jointly and together constitute the whole question for this catalytic system.

References

  1. Ana Conde, Gerard Sabenya, Mònica Rodríguez, Verònica Postils, Josep M. Luis, M. Mar Díaz-Requejo, Miquel Costas, Pedro J. Pérez. Iron and Manganese Catalysts for the Selective Functionalization of Arene C(sp²)−H Bonds by Carbene Insertion. Angewandte Chemie International Edition 2016, 55, 6530–6534. DOI 10.1002/anie.201601750. https://doi.org/10.1002/anie.201601750
  2. Verònica Postils, Mònica Rodríguez, Gerard Sabenya, Ana Conde, M. Mar Díaz-Requejo, Pedro J. Pérez, Miquel Costas, Miquel Solà, Josep M. Luis. Mechanism of the Selective Fe-Catalyzed Arene Carbon–Hydrogen Bond Functionalization. ACS Catalysis 2018, 8, 4313–4322. DOI 10.1021/acscatal.7b03935. https://doi.org/10.1021/acscatal.7b03935
  3. Claire Empel, Sripati Jana, Rene M. Koenigs. C-H Functionalization via Iron-Catalyzed Carbene-Transfer Reactions. Molecules 2020, 25, 880. DOI 10.3390/molecules25040880. https://doi.org/10.3390/molecules25040880
  4. Manuel R. Fructos, Maria Besora, Ataualpa A. C. Braga, M. Mar Díaz-Requejo, Feliu Maseras, Pedro J. Pérez. Mechanistic Studies on Gold-Catalyzed Direct Arene C–H Bond Functionalization by Carbene Insertion: The Coinage-Metal Effect. Organometallics 2017, 36, 172–179. DOI 10.1021/acs.organomet.6b00604. https://doi.org/10.1021/acs.organomet.6b00604
  5. Alberto Hernán-Gómez, Mònica Rodríguez, Teodor Parella, Miquel Costas. Electrophilic Iron Catalyst Paired with a Lithium Cation Enables Selective Functionalization of Non-Activated Aliphatic C−H Bonds via Metallocarbene Intermediates. Angewandte Chemie International Edition 2019, 58, 13904–13911. DOI 10.1002/anie.201905986. https://doi.org/10.1002/anie.201905986
  6. Mònica Rodríguez, Gemma Font, Joel Nadal-Moradell, Alberto Hernán-Gómez, Miquel Costas. Iron-Catalyzed Intermolecular Functionalization of Non-Activated Aliphatic C−H Bonds via Carbene Transfer Reactions. Advanced Synthesis & Catalysis 2020, 362, 5116–5123. DOI 10.1002/adsc.202000817. https://doi.org/10.1002/adsc.202000817
  7. Yuan He, Zilong Huang, Kaikai Wu, Juan Ma, Yong-Gui Zhou, Zhengkun Yu. Recent advances in transition-metal-catalyzed carbene insertion to C–H bonds. Chemical Society Reviews 2022, 51, 2759–2852. DOI 10.1039/d1cs00895a. https://doi.org/10.1039/d1cs00895a
  8. Reena Balhara, Ritwika Chatterjee, Garima Jindal. Mechanism and stereoselectivity in metal and enzyme catalyzed carbene insertion into X–H and C(sp²)–H bonds. Chemical Society Reviews 2024, 53, 11004–11044. DOI 10.1039/d4cs00742e. https://doi.org/10.1039/d4cs00742e
  9. Vasco F. Batista, Diana C. G. A. Pinto, Artur M. S. Silva. Iron: A Worthy Contender in Metal Carbene Chemistry. ACS Catalysis 2020, 10, 10096–10116. DOI 10.1021/acscatal.0c02776. https://doi.org/10.1021/acscatal.0c02776
  10. Ben Ma, Zhaowei Chu, Ben Huang, Zhenli Liu, Lu Liu, Junliang Zhang. Highly para-Selective C−H Alkylation of Benzene Derivatives with 2,2,2-Trifluoroethyl α-Aryl-α-Diazoesters. Angewandte Chemie International Edition 2017, 56, 2749–2753. DOI 10.1002/anie.201611809. https://doi.org/10.1002/anie.201611809
  11. Zhunzhun Yu, Guanghui Li, Junliang Zhang, Lu Liu. Iron-catalysed chemo- and ortho-selective C–H bond functionalization of phenols with α-aryl-α-diazoacetates. Organic Chemistry Frontiers 2021, 8, 3770–3775. DOI 10.1039/D1QO00276G. https://doi.org/10.1039/D1QO00276G
  12. Balu S. Navale, Debasish Laha, Subhrashis Banerjee, Kumar Vanka, Ramakrishna G. Bhat. Highly Site-Selective Direct C−H Bond Functionalization of Unactivated Arenes with Propargyl α-Aryl-α-diazoacetates via Scandium Catalysis. The Journal of Organic Chemistry 2022, 87, 13583–13597. DOI 10.1021/acs.joc.2c01185. https://doi.org/10.1021/acs.joc.2c01185
  13. Natalie Holmberg-Douglas, Nicholas P. R. Onuska, David A. Nicewicz. Regioselective Arene C−H Alkylation Enabled by Organic Photoredox Catalysis. Angewandte Chemie International Edition 2020, 59, 7425–7429. DOI 10.1002/anie.202000684. https://doi.org/10.1002/anie.202000684
  14. Juner Zhang, Ailiena O. Maggiolo, Edwin Alfonzo, Runze Mao, Nicholas J. Porter, Nayla M. Abney, Frances H. Arnold. Chemodivergent C(sp³)–H and C(sp²)–H cyanomethylation using engineered carbene transferases. Nature Catalysis 2023, 6, 152–160. DOI 10.1038/s41929-022-00908-x. https://doi.org/10.1038/s41929-022-00908-x
  15. Àlex Díaz-Jiménez, Roger Monreal-Corona, Arijit Saha, Andrea Álvarez-Núñez, Anna Company, Teodor Parella, Pedro J. Pérez, Ana Caballero, Anna Roglans, Albert Poater, Anna Pla-Quintana. Characterization of a Silver Vinylcarbene Intermediate in Carbene–Alkyne Metathesis and Its Concerted C(sp²)–H Bond Insertion. Journal of the American Chemical Society 2026, 148, 3689–3696. DOI 10.1021/jacs.5c19806. https://doi.org/10.1021/jacs.5c19806
  16. Reena Balhara, Garima Jindal. Does an Enol Pathway Preclude High Stereoselectivity in Iron-Catalyzed Indole C–H Functionalization via Carbene Insertion? The Journal of Organic Chemistry 2022, 87, 7919–7933. DOI 10.1021/acs.joc.2c00573. https://doi.org/10.1021/acs.joc.2c00573
  17. Garima Jindal, Dev Dodiya, Mahesh Singh Harariya. Metal-Associated Enols as Key Intermediates in Controlling Enantioselectivity in Carbene Insertion Reactions. Synlett 2025, 36, 817–825. DOI 10.1055/s-0043-1775445. https://doi.org/10.1055/s-0043-1775445
  18. Arushi Tyagi, Kriti Gupta, Garima Jindal. Cu-Catalyzed Asymmetric Carbene Insertion into N–H, O–H, and S–H Bonds: Challenging the Existing Mechanistic Dogma. JACS Au 2025, 5, 4879–4892. DOI 10.1021/jacsau.5c00807. https://doi.org/10.1021/jacsau.5c00807