Symbiotic nitrogen fixation in root nodules is confined to a single clade of flowering plants (the nitrogen-fixing clade, NFC). Werner and colleagues (2014) showed quantitatively that this restriction is best explained by a single 'potentiating' innovation — a cryptic precursor that arose over 100 million years ago in the NFC ancestor, was retained in some lineages for over 100 million years, and from which full nodulation evolved several times independently. The identity of that precursor — which genetic, regulatory, or morphological change made only this clade competent to form nitrogen-fixing nodules — remains the central open problem. Twelve years of comparative genomics have transformed the question: massive parallel loss of symbiosis genes supports a single deep origin, new phylogenetic models favor multiple independent gains from a hidden precursor state, and the discovery of PACE, a cis-regulatory element in the NIN promoter found exclusively in the NFC and sufficient to drive infection-thread formation, provides the first concrete candidate for the potentiating change. A 2026 preprint adds a further landmark: repairing NIN functionality alone induced nodule-like organogenesis in strawberry, a non-nodulating member of the clade, whereas equivalent NIN engineering in barley outside the clade produced only altered root development. What remains unresolved is whether PACE, alone or together with receptor-complex changes, is the precursor — a claim requiring demonstration across the clade that it is necessary for, though not by itself productive of, nodulation competence, against the background of the unsettled competing single-origin versus convergent-assembly histories.

Background

A few dozen plant families cannot use atmospheric nitrogen directly; some species compensate by hosting nitrogen-fixing bacteria (rhizobia or the actinomycete Frankia) inside specialized root organs called nodules, a trait called root nodule symbiosis (RNS). Actinorhizal plants (nodulated by Frankia) and legumes (nodulated by rhizobia) together define the symbiotic nitrogen-fixing condition. Strikingly, nearly all nodulating angiosperms fall within one rosid lineage, the nitrogen-fixing clade (NFC, also called FaFaCuRo after its four orders Fabales, Fagales, Cucurbitales, and Rosales), yet within that clade nodulators and non-nodulators are interleaved at every level. From the first chloroplast phylogenies, Soltis et al. (1995) therefore proposed that the NFC ancestor acquired a 'predisposition' — some change that does not itself nodulate but makes nodulation far more likely to evolve. Werner et al. (2014) quantified this with state-dependent speciation-and-extinction-style trait models on a comprehensive database: a single origin of a cryptic precursor about 100 million years ago (MYA), followed by roughly eight independent origins of full nitrogen-fixing symbiosis from precursor-bearing lineages and about ten losses, with some lineages retaining an unused precursor for over 100 million years. They framed the result using potentiation, actualization, and refinement — the three stages of complex-trait evolution borrowed from microbial experimental evolution: the precursor is the potentiating change; the later independent origins are actualizations; and a persisting 'stable fixer' state, which evolved roughly 24 times (possibly aided in Papilionoideae by a whole-genome duplication, WGD, i.e. a genome doubling event), represents refinement. The mechanistic machinery is partially known. Nodulation recruits the much older arbuscular mycorrhizal symbiosis pathway: the common symbiosis signaling pathway (CSSP), conserved across land plants, including the receptor-like kinase SymRK. Bacterial partners signal via lipo-chitooligosaccharides (LCOs, 'Nod factors') recognized by LysM-type receptors such as Nod Factor Perception (NFP). Downstream, the transcription factor Nodule Inception (NIN), a member of the NIN-like protein (NLP) nitrate-response family, is the master regulator of nodule organogenesis and intracellular infection. Werner et al. noted that the precursor might be a modification of this shared mycorrhizal-symbiosis toolkit, but that a SymRK variant from outside the NFC can mediate symbiotic function, ruling SymRK out as the sole explanation; an environmental cause was argued against because only one precursor event was inferred across about 53 billion lineage-years. After 2014 the field moved in two directions. First, genome-scale evidence of loss: van Velzen et al. (2018) and Griesmann et al. (2018) showed that non-nodulating NFC species carry pseudogenized remnants of NIN, RPG (a gene for rhizobium-directed polar growth), and NFP, implying these lineages descended from nodulating or predisposed ancestors — a 'single origin followed by massive parallel loss' picture. Second, a counter-current: Li et al. (2015) and especially Kates et al. (2024), using the largest NFC phylogeny with hidden-rate models (phylogenetic models that allow unobserved 'hidden' character states), argued for multiple independent gains of RNS from an unidentified precursor state that arose even deeper in the rosids, and Finegan et al. (2025) found that the LCO-receptor gene NFP was recruited convergently (the legume NFP and the Cucurbitales/Rosales NFP genes descend from different duplications), giving a molecular mechanism for multiple gains. Doyle et al. (2025) crystallized the resulting impasse: because every component of nodulation was assembled from pre-existing processes (mainly mycorrhizal signaling and lateral-root programs), any feature can be read either as descent from one origin or as convergence, so discriminating tests are needed and mostly do not yet exist. Within this debate, the deepest new mechanistic result concerns NIN regulation: Cathebras et al. (2026) discovered PACE (Predisposition-Associated Cis-regulatory Element), a short promoter element upstream of NIN that occurs exclusively in NFC genomes (in nodulators and in non-nodulators that still retain intact NIN), is required for infection-thread formation (infection threads are plant-derived intracellular tunnels through which the symbiotic bacteria enter root cells) in the model legume Lotus japonicus, functions equivalently when swapped between the four NFC orders, and, when engineered into the NIN promoter of tomato (a non-NFC plant), restores cortical infection-thread formation in a Lotus assay — leading the authors to propose PACE as the key invention that wired NIN into the ancient mycorrhizal signaling cascade. Liu et al. (2026) complemented this by showing that non-symbiotic NIN orthologs can already perform intracellular infection and nodule initiation, so the NIN protein itself was pre-adapted and the crucial evolutionary change was regulatory. Geurts and Huisman (2024) similarly argue that the first adaptations were changes in the LCO receptor complex plus the recruitment of NIN. A 2026 preprint (Kundu et al. 2026) pushes the NIN-centric, single-origin side further: the NIN-controlled organogenesis program is fully conserved between the actinorhizal nodulator Datisca glomerata and the legume Medicago truncatula, and repairing NIN functionality in strawberry — a non-nodulating rosoid within the NFC — induced nodule-like development, whereas equivalent engineering in barley, outside the NFC, produced only altered root development, consistent with the potentiating machinery being absent outside the clade. Taken together, the field now has a concrete candidate answer to a question that in 2014 had none — but the candidate's necessity and sufficiency across the clade, its fate at the multiple origins proposed by the two-step models, and indeed the single-versus-multiple assembly history itself, all remain unsettled.

Problem Statement

Determine the biological correlate(s) of the potentiating precursor of symbiotic nitrogen fixation: identify the specific genetic, regulatory, or morphological change(s) that arose in the lineage ancestral to the nitrogen-fixing clade (NFC) over 100 million years ago (the working hypothesis of the single-origin model; a competing reading places the precursor state deeper in the rosids), that are necessary for — though do not by themselves produce — root nodule symbiosis, and that explain why this capability is confined to this one clade of flowering plants. An accepted answer must (i) specify the candidate change at molecular resolution, (ii) demonstrate its distribution is consistent with the inferred precursor history (present in NFC lineages that retain the potential to nodulate, lost where the potential was lost, and absent outside the clade under the single-origin reading — or, where the answer instead places the precursor state deeper in the rosids, distributed as that placement requires and argued explicitly), and (iii) establish that the candidate is necessary for acquiring nodulation competence while not by itself producing root nodule symbiosis, the potentiating phenotype in question being intracellular bacterial uptake via infection-thread-like structures and the capacity for nodule organogenesis. The two secondary open threads raised by the source — the heterogeneous, clade-specific genetic bases of the repeatedly evolved 'stable fixer' state, and why the potentiating event occurred only once across angiosperm history — fall within the problem's scope as supporting sub-questions whose resolution should be consistent with, but is not required for, the identification of the precursor.

References

  1. Werner GDA, Cornwell WK, Sprent JI, Kattge J, Kiers ET (2014). A single evolutionary innovation drives the deep evolution of symbiotic N2-fixation in angiosperms. Nature Communications 5:4087. DOI: 10.1038/ncomms5087. https://doi.org/10.1038/ncomms5087
  2. Soltis DE, Soltis PS, Morgan DR, Swensen SM, Mullin BC, Dowd JM, Martin PG (1995). Chloroplast gene sequence data suggest a single origin of the predisposition for symbiotic nitrogen fixation in angiosperms. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences USA 92(7):2647-2651. DOI: 10.1073/pnas.92.7.2647. https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.92.7.2647
  3. Li H-L, Wang W, Mortimer PE, Li R-Q, Li D-Z, Hyde KD, Xu J-C, Soltis DE, Chen Z-D (2015). Large-scale phylogenetic analyses reveal multiple gains of actinorhizal nitrogen-fixing symbioses in angiosperms associated with climate change. Scientific Reports 5:14023. DOI: 10.1038/srep14023. https://doi.org/10.1038/srep14023
  4. van Velzen R, Holmer R, Bu F, Rutten L, van Zeijl A, Liu W, Santuari L, Cao Q, Sharma T, Shen D, Roswanjaya Y, Wardhani TAK, Kalhor MS, Jansen J, van den Hoogen J, Gungor B, Hartog M, Hontelez J, Verver J, Yang W-C, Schijlen E, Repin R, Schilthuizen M, Schranz ME, Heidstra R, Miyata K, Fedorova E, Kohlen W, Bisseling T, Smit S, Geurts R (2018). Comparative genomics of the nonlegume Parasponia reveals insights into evolution of nitrogen-fixing rhizobium symbioses. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences USA 115(20):E4700-E4709. DOI: 10.1073/pnas.1721395115. https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.1721395115
  5. Griesmann M, Chang Y, Liu X, Song Y, Haberer G, Crook MB, Billault-Penneteau B, Lauressergues D, Keller J, Imanishi L, Roswanjaya YP, Kohlen W, Pujic P, Battenberg K, Alloisio N, Liang Y, Hilhorst H, Salgado MG, Hocher V, Gherbi H, Svistoonoff S, Doyle JJ, He S, Xu Y, Xu S, Qu J, Gao Q, Fang X, Fu Y, Normand P, Berry AM, Wall LG, Ane J-M, Pawlowski K, Xu X, Yang H, Spannagl M, Mayer KFX, Wong GK-S, Parniske M, Delaux P-M, Cheng S (2018). Phylogenomics reveals multiple losses of nitrogen-fixing root nodule symbiosis. Science 361(6398):eaat1743. DOI: 10.1126/science.aat1743. https://doi.org/10.1126/science.aat1743
  6. Zhang Y, Fu Y, Xian W, Li X, Feng Y, Bu F, Shi Y, Chen S, van Velzen R, Battenberg K, Berry AM, Salgado MG, Liu H, Yi T, Fournier P, Alloisio N, Pujic P, Boubakri H, Schranz ME, Delaux P-M, Wong GK-S, Hocher V, Svistoonoff S, Gherbi H, Wang E, Kohlen W, Wall LG, Parniske M, Pawlowski K, Normand P, Doyle JJ, Cheng S (2024). Comparative phylogenomics and phylotranscriptomics provide insights into the genetic complexity of nitrogen-fixing root-nodule symbiosis. Plant Communications 5(1):100671. DOI: 10.1016/j.xplc.2023.100671. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.xplc.2023.100671
  7. Geurts R, Huisman R (2024). Innovations in two genes kickstarted the evolution of nitrogen-fixing nodules. Current Opinion in Plant Biology 77:102446. DOI: 10.1016/j.pbi.2023.102446. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.pbi.2023.102446
  8. Kates HR, O'Meara BC, LaFrance R, Stull GW, James EK, Liu S-Y, Tian Q, Yi T-S, Conde D, Kirst M, Ane J-M, Soltis DE, Guralnick RP, Soltis PS, Folk RA (2024). Shifts in evolutionary lability underlie independent gains and losses of root-nodule symbiosis in a single clade of plants. Nature Communications 15:4262. DOI: 10.1038/s41467-024-48036-3. https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-024-48036-3
  9. Finegan C, Kates HR, Guralnick RP, Soltis PS, Resende MFR, Ane J-M, Kirst M, Folk RA, Soltis DE (2025). Convergent evolution of NFP-facilitated root nodule symbiosis. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences USA 122(37):e2424902122. DOI: 10.1073/pnas.2424902122. https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.2424902122
  10. Doyle JJ, Ren J, Pawlowski K, James EK, Gao Y (2025). One versus many independent assemblies of symbiotic nitrogen fixation in flowering plants. Nature Communications 16:5345. DOI: 10.1038/s41467-025-60433-w. https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-025-60433-w
  11. Cathebras C, Gong X, Andrade RE, Vondenhoff K, Keller J, Delaux P-M, Hayashi M, Griesmann M, Parniske M (2026). A novel cis-element enabled bacterial uptake by plant cells. Nature Plants 12(1):140-151. DOI: 10.1038/s41477-025-02161-z. https://doi.org/10.1038/s41477-025-02161-z (preprint: DOI 10.1101/2022.03.28.486070)
  12. Liu J, Yan S, Li M, Shen D, Ticha M, Baerentsen R, Andersen KR, Verbeek F, Kulikova O, Geurts R, Bisseling T, Huisman R (2026). Ancestral functionality and symbiotic refinement of NIN in root nodule symbiosis. Nature Communications 17:4907. DOI: 10.1038/s41467-026-71330-1. https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-026-71330-1
  13. Sexauer M, Markmann K (2026). The roots of nodules: a shared genetic infrastructure of root lateral organs suggests a common origin. Journal of Experimental Botany. DOI: 10.1093/jxb/erag088. https://doi.org/10.1093/jxb/erag088
  14. Kundu A, Price RJ, Sanchez ER, Reynas-Llorens I, Jhu M, Gao J-P, Moraes TA, Marangelli F, Libourel C, Keller J, Brooks J, Harwood W, Wallington EJ, Delaux P-M, Harrison RJ, Oldroyd GED (2026). The demonstration of a single origin for nodule evolution, with nodule engineering in a non-nodulating species. bioRxiv preprint, posted 3 June 2026. DOI: 10.64898/2026.05.31.728964. https://doi.org/10.64898/2026.05.31.728964