When α-(3-chloro-2-butenyl)ketones — masked 1,5-diketones obtained by enolate alkylation with 1,3-dichloro-cis-2-butene — are heated in strongly protonating, weakly basic organic media such as formic acid, acetic acid, or nitromethane mixed 9:1 with perchloric acid, they cyclize to Δ2-cyclohexenones in high to moderate yields, whereas the classical Wichterle conditions (concentrated sulfuric acid) deliver bridged bicyclic ketones, hydrolyzed 1,5-diketones, or resin. Kobayashi and Matsumoto, who discovered this 'modified Wichterle reaction' in 1973, proposed that protonation of the side-chain double bond gives a tertiary carbocation that converts — directly or via a cyclic, neighboring-group-assisted intermediate — into a 1,5-diketone-type intermediate, which then cyclizes by intramolecular aldol condensation. The follow-up literature: the authors' own 1975 and 1979 papers extended the substrate scope, demonstrated stepwise intermediates only in an aromatic (phenalenone) series, and isolated 1,5-diketones under Lewis-acid (AlCl3) conditions; a 1993 review and modern reference works consolidate the synthetic method; and the field's preferred modern variant became the Stork–Jung vinylsilane annulation. No study in the subsequent literature directly detected the proposed intermediates in the perchloric-acid media, determined the protonation site, quantified the roles of solvent basicity, acid strength, and water, or rationalized which substrates give which product class. The mechanistic core of the 1973 question therefore remains open.

Background

The Robinson annulation is the classical route to a six-membered α,β-unsaturated ketone: the enolate of a ketone adds in a Michael addition (nucleophilic conjugate addition) to methyl vinyl ketone (MVK), and the resulting 1,5-diketone — a chain bearing carbonyls at positions 1 and 5 — closes by an intramolecular aldol condensation to a cyclohexenone with loss of water. Its practical weakness is MVK itself, which polymerizes and undergoes side reactions under the basic conditions of the Michael step. The Wichterle reaction, discovered by Otto Wichterle in 1947, avoids MVK: a ketone enolate is alkylated with 1,3-dichloro-cis-2-butene to give an α-(3-chloro-2-butenyl)ketone, in which the vinylic (alkenyl) chloride is a masked 3-oxobutyl group; treatment with concentrated sulfuric acid converts the vinylic chloride into a ketone — the formal hydrolysis of a vinyl chloride, the defining step of the Wichterle reaction — unmasking a 1,5-diketone that then cyclizes, so the whole sequence is a formal alternative to the Robinson annulation. The classical conditions are capricious: the strongly acidic medium promotes competing cationic cyclizations to bridged bicyclic ketones (Dauben and McFarland showed in 1960 that 1,5-diketones themselves rearrange to such bridged products in sulfuric acid, and Marshall and Schaeffer deliberately exploited this in 1965 to make bicyclo[4.4.0]decane- and bicyclo[3.3.1]nonane-type ketones), stops at the hydrolyzed open-chain 1,5-diketone for some substrates, and generates resinous side products; outcomes depended on substrate and acid in ways that were not predictable.

In 1973, Kobayashi and Matsumoto (Chemistry Letters, 1973, 2, 957–960) discovered that replacing concentrated sulfuric acid by strongly protonating but weakly basic organic media — formic acid, acetic acid, or nitromethane mixed 9:1 v/v with perchloric acid — channels α-(3-chloro-2-butenyl)ketones to Δ2-cyclohexenones (cyclohex-2-en-1-ones; in ring-annulated cases, octalones such as 4a-methyl-Δ1(8a)-2-octalone) in high to moderate yields, up to 98% isolated for the model substrate 2-methyl-2-(3-chloro-2-butenyl)cyclohexanone, for which sulfuric acid instead gives the bridged 2,5-dimethylbicyclo[3.3.1]non-2-en-9-one. Two empirical rules emerged from their solvent survey: cyclization occurs only in solvents that are weaker bases toward the proton than a simple olefin (pKb above roughly 18; formic and acetic acid, nitromethane), whereas more basic solvents (ethanol, dioxane) return starting material; and water appears to be required for the key step. They proposed a mechanism: protonation of the side-chain C=C bond gives a tertiary carbocation (intermediate 4 in the paper), which converts — directly, or via a cyclic intermediate formed by neighboring-group participation (5), that is, intramolecular assistance of the developing cation by a nearby group within the same molecule through a bridged structure — into a 1,5-diketone-type intermediate (6) that cyclizes by intramolecular aldol condensation and dehydration to the Δ2-cyclohexenone (3). Primary protonation at the ketone oxygen was considered less likely, in part because even a carbonyl-free bis-chloroolefin substrate cyclizes to the enone.

The proposal was, and remained, a working hypothesis. No intermediate was ever detected or trapped in the perchloric-acid media; the pKb correlation used textbook values for the neat liquids rather than protonation equilibria in the actual mixed strongly acidic media; the water requirement was inferred from a comparison that also changed the solvent identity; and the paper's substrate table mapped, but did not rationalize, which chlorobutenylated ketones give Δ2-cyclohexenones, which give cyclic α,β:γ,δ-unsaturated ketones (enones whose C=C conjugated to the carbonyl is part of a second, more remote double bond), which stop at hydrolyzed 1,5-diketones, and which rearrange to bridged products or resinify. The mechanistic and selectivity questions posed by this discovery — what the elementary steps are, where protonation occurs, how the medium controls the outcome, and why substrates diverge — have not been answered by the subsequent literature, even though the synthetic side of the field consolidated around the reaction's practical successor, the Stork–Jung vinylsilane annulation (in which a silicon-substituted alkene serves as a masked carbonyl group that is unmasked under electrophilic conditions), and Hudlický's 1993 review of the Wichterle reaction.

Problem Statement

Determine, with direct experimental evidence and/or computation validated against the empirical observations of the source papers, the mechanism by which α-(3-chloro-2-butenyl)ketones are converted into Δ2-cyclohexenones when heated in strongly protonating, weakly basic organic media (formic acid, acetic acid, or nitromethane mixed ca. 9:1 v/v with perchloric acid), as discovered by Kobayashi and Matsumoto in 1973. The account must establish the sequence of elementary steps: the site of the initial protonation (the side-chain C=C bond versus the ketone oxygen) and the nature, lifetime, and interconversion of the proposed intermediates — the tertiary carbocation formed by olefin protonation, the possible cyclic neighboring-group-assisted intermediate, and the 1,5-diketone-type intermediate that cyclizes by intramolecular aldol condensation and dehydration — i.e., whether the 1,5-diketone is reached directly or via neighboring-group participation. The mechanistic account must be consistent with the source papers' empirical observations: cyclization occurs only in strongly protonating media that are weaker bases toward the proton than a simple olefin, whereas more basic solvents return starting material; water appears to be required for the key step; and the product course diverges across substrates and acids, giving Δ2-cyclohexenones (octalones) in the perchloric-acid media versus bridged bicyclic ketones, hydrolyzed 1,5-diketones, or resinous side products under conditions such as concentrated sulfuric acid.

References

  1. Makoto Kobayashi and Takeshi Matsumoto, 'MODIPIZIERTE WICHTERLE REAKTION. EIN NEUER WEG ZUR SYNTHESE VON Δ2-CYCLOHEXENONEN', Chemistry Letters, 1973, 2(9), 957–960. DOI: 10.1246/cl.1973.957, https://doi.org/10.1246/cl.1973.957
  2. Otto Wichterle, 'Transformation des chlorures du type vinylique en cétones', Collection of Czechoslovak Chemical Communications, 1947, 12, 93–100. DOI: 10.1135/cccc19470093, https://doi.org/10.1135/cccc19470093
  3. Otto Wichterle, J. Procházka, and J. Hofman, 'L'acétylacétate γ-chlorocrotylé et sa cyclisation par l'acide sulfurique', Collection of Czechoslovak Chemical Communications, 1948, 13, 300–315. DOI: 10.1135/cccc19480300, https://doi.org/10.1135/cccc19480300
  4. William G. Dauben and James W. McFarland, 'The Reaction of 1,5-Diketones with Sulfuric Acid', Journal of the American Chemical Society, 1960, 82(16), 4245–4248. DOI: 10.1021/ja01501a032, https://doi.org/10.1021/ja01501a032
  5. James A. Marshall and David J. Schaeffer, 'Synthesis of Bicyclo[4.4.0]decanones and Bicyclo[3.3.1]nonanones via the Wichterle Reaction', The Journal of Organic Chemistry, 1965, 30(11), 3642–3646. DOI: 10.1021/jo01022a013, https://doi.org/10.1021/jo01022a013
  6. Makoto Kobayashi and Takeshi Matsumoto, 'Ungewöhnliche Wichterle-Reaktionen. Eine Neue Synthese von Phenalenonen', Bulletin of the Chemical Society of Japan, 1975, 48(10), 2935–2938. DOI: 10.1246/bcsj.48.2935, https://doi.org/10.1246/bcsj.48.2935
  7. Makoto Kobayashi and Takeshi Matsumoto, 'Modifizierte Wichterle-Reaktion. Ein Weg zur Darstellung von 2-Cyclohexenonen und 1,4-Diketonen. Synthese von 4-Estren-3,17-dion und Dihydrojasmon', Bulletin of the Chemical Society of Japan, 1979, 52(10), 2978–2990. DOI: 10.1246/bcsj.52.2978, https://doi.org/10.1246/bcsj.52.2978
  8. Hidetoshi Yoshioka, Kazuhiko Takasaki, Makoto Kobayashi, and Takeshi Matsumoto, 'Modifizierte Wichterle-Reaktion. Eine neue Methode zur Hydrolyse von Vinylchloriden zu Ketonen', Tetrahedron Letters, 1979, 20(37), 3489–3492. DOI: 10.1016/s0040-4039(01)95442-5, https://doi.org/10.1016/s0040-4039(01)95442-5
  9. Makoto Kobayashi, Naoki Fujiyama, Hidetoshi Yoshioka, and Takeshi Matsumoto, 'MODIFIZIERTE WICHTERLE-REAKTION: EINE AlCl3-INDUZIERTE UMWANDLUNG VON VINYLCHLORIDEN IN KETONE', Chemistry Letters, 1979, 8(7), 837–840. DOI: 10.1246/cl.1979.837, https://doi.org/10.1246/cl.1979.837
  10. Miloš Hudlický, 'The Wichterle Reaction', Collection of Czechoslovak Chemical Communications, 1993, 58(10), 2229–2244. DOI: 10.1135/cccc19932229, https://doi.org/10.1135/cccc19932229
  11. Gilbert Stork and Michael E. Jung, 'Vinylsilanes as carbonyl precursors. Use in annelation reactions', Journal of the American Chemical Society, 1974, 96(11), 3682–3684. DOI: 10.1021/ja00818a070, https://doi.org/10.1021/ja00818a070
  12. 'Wichterle Reaction', in Comprehensive Organic Name Reactions and Reagents, Wiley, 2010, pp. 3003–3007 (reference-work entry). DOI: 10.1002/9780470638859.conrr669, https://doi.org/10.1002/9780470638859.conrr669
  13. R. B. Gammill and T. A. Bryson, 'Vinylogous thioester chemistry: the total synthesis of desmethyl-β-cyperone', Tetrahedron Letters, 1975, 16(44), 3793–3796. DOI: 10.1016/s0040-4039(00)91275-9, https://doi.org/10.1016/s0040-4039(00)91275-9
  14. R. B. Gammill and T. A. Bryson, 'A New Synthesis and the 13C-NMR of β-Cyperone. 1,3-Dibromo-2-Pentene, A New Ethyl Vinyl Ketone Equivalent', Synthetic Communications, 1976, 6(3), 209–215. DOI: 10.1080/00397917608072632, https://doi.org/10.1080/00397917608072632
  15. Michael E. Jung, 'A review of annulation', Tetrahedron, 1976, 32(1), 3–31. DOI: 10.1016/0040-4020(76)80016-6, https://doi.org/10.1016/0040-4020(76)80016-6
  16. M. Kobayashi and T. Matsumoto, 'ChemInform Abstract: MODIFIZIERTE WICHTERLE-REAKTION, EIN NEUER WEG ZUR SYNTHESE VON DELTA(2)-CYCLOHEXENONEN', Chemischer Informationsdienst, 1974, 5(9) (abstracting-service record of the 1973 source paper). DOI: 10.1002/chin.197409254, https://doi.org/10.1002/chin.197409254
  17. Howard E. Morton and M. Robert Leanna, 'Synthesis of α-halomethyl ketones: Oxidative hydrolysis of vinyl halides', Tetrahedron Letters, 1993, 34(28), 4481–4484. DOI: 10.1016/0040-4039(93)88064-p, https://doi.org/10.1016/0040-4039(93)88064-p
  18. Susumu Saito, Itsuro Shimada, Yusuke Takamori, Michiaki Tanaka, Keiji Maruoka, and Hisashi Yamamoto, 'Regioselective Robinson Annulation Realized by the Combined Use of Lithium Enolates and Aluminum Tris(2,6-diphenylphenoxide) (ATPH)', Bulletin of the Chemical Society of Japan, 1997, 70(7), 1671–1681. DOI: 10.1246/bcsj.70.1671, https://doi.org/10.1246/bcsj.70.1671
  19. Richard C. Larock, Anton V. Dubrovskiy, and Nataliya A. Markina, 'Formation of Aldehydes and Ketones by Cyclization and Annulation Reactions', in Comprehensive Organic Transformations, Wiley, 2018, pp. 1–61 (reference-work chapter). DOI: 10.1002/9781118662083.cot08-006, https://doi.org/10.1002/9781118662083.cot08-006