Developing lymphoid progenitors choose between T, B, and innate lymphoid cell (ILC) fates in response to two microenvironmental signals, interleukin-7 (IL-7) and Notch. Work in the mouse showed that the concentration of IL-7 and the strength and duration of Notch ligand exposure bias these fate decisions, and that RORγt+ ILCs develop Notch-independently in the fetus but Notch2-dependently in the adult. What remains open is the integrative mechanism: how IL-7/STAT5 and Notch magnitude and duration are quantitatively converted into the balance of lineage-specifying transcription factors (NFIL3, TCF-1, Id2, E-proteins, RORγt) that gates commitment; which cells in the fetal liver and adult peripheral tissues actually supply IL-7 and the Notch ligands DLL1, DLL4, or Jagged, at which anatomical sites and times, to generate the physiological exposures inferred to specify lineage choice; and what molecularly renders fetal RORγt+ ILC development Notch-independent while adult progenitors require peripheral Notch2-dependent cues to stabilize and complete Rorc (RORγt) induction. Recent work has resolved components — an apex role of NFIL3 in ILC specification, a Notch-E2A-Id2 feedback amplifier enforcing T-cell over ILC fate, Notch2-dependent maturation of intestinal NKp46+ ILC3s, and a Notch-RORC-IL-23R cascade in human ILC progenitors in vitro — but no study supplies the quantitative input-output mapping, the in vivo signal-source identification, or the fetal-versus-adult switching mechanism. The problem asks for this missing mechanistic account.

Background

Innate lymphoid cells (ILCs) are tissue-resident lymphocytes that lack antigen receptors (the receptors generated by V(D)J recombination in T and B cells) yet produce the same effector cytokines as T helper subsets; they arise from the common lymphoid progenitor (CLP), a bone-marrow or fetal-liver cell defined by absence of lineage markers combined with CD127 (the IL-7 receptor α chain), Flt3, Sca-1, and c-Kit staining. Along the ILC path, CLPs give rise to early innate lymphoid progenitors (EILPs), then to committed ILC precursors: the common helper ILC precursor (CHILP, marked by the transcription factor Id2) and the PLZF+ ILC precursor (ILCP), which retain potential for all helper ILC subsets; the lymphoid tissue inducer (LTi) branch, defined by the nuclear receptor RORγt (encoded by Rorc), branches off earlier and drives formation of lymph nodes and Peyer's patches. The lineage-specifying transcription factors at this branch point are: NFIL3 (nuclear factor interleukin-3 regulated, a bZIP transcription factor required for CHILP emergence), TCF-1 (encoded by Tcf7, a T-cell factor/LEF family protein required for both T-cell and early ILC development), Id2 (an inhibitor of DNA binding that antagonizes E-proteins), and the E-proteins themselves (E2A/TCF3, E2-2, and HEB — bHLH transcription factors, including the spliced forms E12/E47 — which are required for B- and T-cell commitment); high Id2 with low E-protein activity favors ILC fates, while high E-protein activity favors adaptive T and B fates. Two extracellular signals govern this network. IL-7, acting through the IL-7 receptor and the JAK/STAT5 pathway (STAT5 = signal transducer and activator of transcription 5), is required for lymphoid survival and proliferation and induces Nfil3 expression in lymphoid precursors. Notch signaling is a contact-dependent pathway in which Delta-like ligands (DLL1, DLL4) or Jagged ligands on a neighboring niche cell bind Notch receptors (Notch1, Notch2) on the progenitor; successive cleavages (by ADAM10 and the γ-secretase complex) release the Notch intracellular domain (NICD), which enters the nucleus and, with the DNA-binding protein RBPJ, activates target genes such as Hes1. Sustained strong Notch1-DLL4 signaling drives T-lineage specification in the thymus; in B cells it is absent; its role at the ILC branch point is dose-, duration-, receptor-, and stage-dependent. Two experimental findings define the open problem. First, Koga and colleagues (2018) showed in vitro that IL-7 concentration and Notch ligand strength and duration differentially bias CLP commitment to B, ILC, and T lineages — intermediate conditions favor ILCs, while continuous strong Notch drives T fate — and that deleting Dll4 from thymic epithelial cells causes ectopic B-cell and ILC expansion in the thymus, yet the authors could not determine how these quantities are mechanistically translated into the transcription-factor balance, and could not identify, among many candidates, the fetal-liver cells that produce IL-7 or express Notch ligands in vivo. Second, Possot and colleagues (2011) showed that fetal RORγt+ ILCs mature Notch-independently in the fetal liver, whereas bone-marrow-derived adult RORγt+ ILCs must leave the marrow and complete their differentiation in peripheral organs (spleen, intestinal lamina propria) in a Notch2-dependent manner — leaving open which peripheral signals stabilize and complete Rorc induction in adults and what makes the fetal environment Notch-independent.

Problem Statement

How are quantitative microenvironmental signals converted into discrete lineage-specifying transcriptional programs in developing lymphoid cells? The open problem, as posed by the source studies and left unresolved by subsequent work, has three linked aspects that jointly constitute one mechanistic question (all three aspects are required, and no single aspect is independently sufficient). (1) Quantitative signal-to-program mapping: determine how differences in IL-7/STAT5 signaling magnitude and in Notch signaling strength and duration are translated into the expression balance of the lineage-specifying transcription factors NFIL3, TCF-1, Id2, E-proteins (and, for the RORγt branch, RORγt itself) in CLP-to-CHILP/ILCP progenitors, and show whether this balance quantitatively and causally determines the T-versus-B-versus-ILC commitment observed in dose- and duration-resolved experiments. (2) Physiological signal sources: identify in vivo which cells produce IL-7 and which cells express the relevant Notch ligands (DLL1 versus DLL4, and Jagged ligands for the adult Notch2-dependent cues), in which anatomical compartment (fetal liver; adult spleen and intestinal lamina propria), and at which developmental times, such that progenitors actually experience the signal exposures inferred to specify lineage choice — the source studies could not narrow these down among candidate stromal, endothelial, and epithelial populations. (3) Fetal-versus-adult Notch asymmetry: identify the peripheral signals that stabilize and complete Rorc induction in adult progenitors (which Notch ligands, delivered by which cells) and the mechanism by which the fetal liver environment renders fetal RORγt+ ILC differentiation Notch-independent. A complete answer supplies a mechanistic, quantitative account connecting physiological signal input (source cell, ligand identity, dose, duration) through the transcription-factor network to discrete lineage output, valid across fetal and adult ontogeny.

References

  1. Satoshi Koga, Katsuto Hozumi, Ken-ichi Hirano, Masaki Yazawa, Tommy Terooatea, Aki Minoda, Takashi Nagasawa, Shigeo Koyasu, Kazuyo Moro (2018). Peripheral PDGFRα+gp38+ mesenchymal cells support the differentiation of fetal liver-derived ILC2. Journal of Experimental Medicine 215(6):1609-1626. DOI: 10.1084/jem.20172310. URL: https://doi.org/10.1084/jem.20172310
  2. Cécilie Possot, Sandrine Schmutz, Sylvestre Chea, Laurent Boucontet, Anne Louise, Ana Cumano, Rachel Golub (2011). Notch signaling is necessary for adult, but not fetal, development of RORγt+ innate lymphoid cells. Nature Immunology 12(10):949-958. DOI: 10.1038/ni.2105. URL: https://doi.org/10.1038/ni.2105
  3. Benjamin C. Harman, William E. Jenkinson, Sonia M. Parnell, Simona W. Rossi, Eric J. Jenkinson, Graham Anderson (2005). T/B lineage choice occurs prior to intrathymic Notch signaling. Blood 106(3):886-892. DOI: 10.1182/blood-2004-12-4881. URL: https://doi.org/10.1182/blood-2004-12-4881
  4. Michael G. Constantinides, Benjamin D. McDonald, Philip A. Verhoef, Albert Bendelac (2014). A committed precursor to innate lymphoid cells. Nature 508(7496):397-401. DOI: 10.1038/nature13047. URL: https://doi.org/10.1038/nature13047
  5. Marie Cherrier, Shinichiro Sawa, Gérard Eberl (2012). Notch, Id2, and RORγt sequentially orchestrate the fetal development of lymphoid tissue inducer cells. Journal of Experimental Medicine 209(4):729-740. DOI: 10.1084/jem.20111594. URL: https://doi.org/10.1084/jem.20111594
  6. Wei Xu, Rita G. Domingues, Diogo Fonseca-Pereira, Manuela Ferreira, Hélder Ribeiro, Silvia Lopez-Lastra, Yasutaka Motomura, Lara Moreira-Santos, Franck Bihl, Véronique Braud, Barbara Kee, Hugh Brady, Mark C. Coles, Christian Vosshenrich, Masato Kubo, James P. Di Santo, Henrique Veiga-Fernandes (2015). NFIL3 orchestrates the emergence of common helper innate lymphoid cell precursors. Cell Reports 10(12):2043-2054. DOI: 10.1016/j.celrep.2015.02.057. URL: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.celrep.2015.02.057
  7. Sylvestre Chea, Sandrine Schmutz, Claire Berthault, Thibaut Perchet, Maxime Petit, Odile Burlen-Defranoux, Ananda W. Goldrath, Hans-Reimer Rodewald, Ana Cumano, Rachel Golub (2016). Single-cell gene expression analyses reveal heterogeneous responsiveness of fetal innate lymphoid progenitors to Notch signaling. Cell Reports 14(6):1500-1516. DOI: 10.1016/j.celrep.2016.01.015. URL: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.celrep.2016.01.015
  8. Sylvestre Chea, Thibaut Perchet, Maxime Petit, Thomas Verrier, Delphine Guy-Grand, Elena-Gaia Banchi, Christian A. J. Vosshenrich, James P. Di Santo, Ana Cumano, Rachel Golub (2016). Notch signaling in group 3 innate lymphoid cells modulates their plasticity. Science Signaling 9(426):ra45. DOI: 10.1126/scisignal.aaf2223. URL: https://doi.org/10.1126/scisignal.aaf2223
  9. Jennifer A. Walker, Paula A. Clark, Alastair Crisp, Jillian L. Barlow, Aydan Szeto, Ana C. F. Ferreira, Batika M. J. Rana, Helen E. Jolin, Noe Rodriguez-Rodriguez, Meera Sivasubramaniam, Richard Pannell, James Cruickshank, Maria Daly, Liora Haim-Vilmovsky, Sarah A. Teichmann, Andrew N. J. McKenzie (2019). Polychromic reporter mice reveal unappreciated innate lymphoid cell progenitor heterogeneity and elusive ILC3 progenitors in bone marrow. Immunity 51(1):104-118. DOI: 10.1016/j.immuni.2019.05.002. URL: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.immuni.2019.05.002
  10. Carys A. Croft, Anna Thaller, Solenne Marie, Jean-Marc Doisne, Laura Surace, Rui Yang, Anne Puel, Jacinta Bustamante, Jean-Laurent Casanova, James P. Di Santo (2022). Notch, RORC and IL-23 signals cooperate to promote multi-lineage human innate lymphoid cell differentiation. Nature Communications 13:4344. DOI: 10.1038/s41467-022-32089-3. URL: https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-022-32089-3
  11. Kazuko Miyazaki, Kenta Horie, Hitomi Watanabe, Reiko Hidaka, Rinako Hayashi, Norihito Hayatsu, Kentaro Fujiwara, Rei Kuwata, Takuya Uehata, Yotaro Ochi, Makoto Takenaka, Risa Karakida Kawaguchi, Koichi Ikuta, Osamu Takeuchi, Seishi Ogawa, Katsuto Hozumi, Georg A. Holländer, Gen Kondoh, Taishin Akiyama, Masaki Miyazaki (2025). A feedback amplifier circuit with Notch and E2A orchestrates T-cell fate and suppresses the innate lymphoid cell lineages during thymic ontogeny. Genes & Development 39(5-6):384-400. DOI: 10.1101/gad.352111.124. URL: https://doi.org/10.1101/gad.352111.124
  12. Joseph Léger, Eva Artano, Delphine Coulais, Naomie Belletoise, Raoudha Fadhloun, Devin Kenney, Avinash Bhandoola, Christelle Harly (2025). The transcription factor NFIL3 drives innate lymphoid cell specification from lymphoid progenitors. Immunity 58(11):2685-2703. DOI: 10.1016/j.immuni.2025.10.005. URL: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.immuni.2025.10.005
  13. Paula A. Clark, Mayuri Gogoi, Noe Rodriguez-Rodriguez, Ana C. F. Ferreira, Jane E. Murphy, Jennifer A. Walker, Alastair Crisp, Helen E. Jolin, Jacqueline D. Shields, Andrew N. J. McKenzie (2024). Recipient tissue microenvironment determines developmental path of intestinal innate lymphoid progenitors. Nature Communications 15:7809. DOI: 10.1038/s41467-024-52155-2. URL: https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-024-52155-2
  14. Michael Schneider, Anneka Allman, Ivan Maillard (2023). Regulation of immune cell development, differentiation and function by stromal Notch ligands. Current Opinion in Cell Biology 85:102256. DOI: 10.1016/j.ceb.2023.102256. URL: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ceb.2023.102256
  15. Arundhoti Das, Yi Ding, Christelle Harly, Avinash Bhandoola (2026). The development of innate lymphoid cells. Nature Immunology 27(3):401-412. DOI: 10.1038/s41590-025-02414-1. URL: https://doi.org/10.1038/s41590-025-02414-1